Generated by the Redline engine from the house's own anonymized sample case: the Ribcage Agent Services packet-validation sample (Bitcoin origins packet) with planted fabricated figures, including wallet positions injected by a corrupted summary. Claimed values and found values are shown side by side.
Verdict: FLAG
Deterministic checks only — arithmetic, consistency, citations. Semantic re-derivation is the desk-review tier.
{
"flags": 4,
"arithmetic_checked": 3,
"arithmetic_failed": 3,
"figures_checked": 12,
"figure_conflicts": 1,
"cross_checked": 0,
"cross_conflicts": 0,
"citations_checked": 0,
"citations_failed": 0,
"quotes_checked": 0,
"quotes_failed": 0
}
| Type | Label | Claimed | Found / computed | Location | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| arithmetic | 7 | 6 | line 8 | "3 + 2 + 1 = 7" — claimed 7, computed 6. | |
| arithmetic | 400 | 352.5 | line 18 | "42.5 + 310 = 400" — claimed 400, computed 352.5. | |
| arithmetic | total | 300 | 250 | line 27 | Table row "Total" column 2 — claimed 300, computed 250 (sum of the 2 rows above). |
| figure_consistency | wallet btc balance | 97.25 | 42.5 | line 20 (first stated line 16) | "Wallet BTC balance" is stated as 42.5 on line 16 and as 97.25 on line 20. |
{
"service": "redline",
"verdict": "FLAG",
"honesty": "Deterministic checks only — arithmetic, consistency, citations. Semantic re-derivation is the desk-review tier.",
"summary": {
"flags": 4,
"arithmetic_checked": 3,
"arithmetic_failed": 3,
"figures_checked": 12,
"figure_conflicts": 1,
"cross_checked": 0,
"cross_conflicts": 0,
"citations_checked": 0,
"citations_failed": 0,
"quotes_checked": 0,
"quotes_failed": 0
},
"checks_run": [
"arithmetic",
"figure_consistency",
"citations"
],
"flags": [
{
"type": "arithmetic",
"claimed": 7,
"found": 6,
"location": "line 8",
"detail": "\"3 + 2 + 1 = 7\" — claimed 7, computed 6."
},
{
"type": "arithmetic",
"claimed": 400,
"found": 352.5,
"location": "line 18",
"detail": "\"42.5 + 310 = 400\" — claimed 400, computed 352.5."
},
{
"type": "arithmetic",
"label": "total",
"claimed": 300,
"found": 250,
"location": "line 27",
"detail": "Table row \"Total\" column 2 — claimed 300, computed 250 (sum of the 2 rows above)."
},
{
"type": "figure_consistency",
"label": "wallet btc balance",
"claimed": 97.25,
"found": 42.5,
"location": "line 20 (first stated line 16)",
"detail": "\"Wallet BTC balance\" is stated as 42.5 on line 16 and as 97.25 on line 20."
}
],
"claims": [
{
"label": "verified claims",
"value": 3,
"line": 5
},
{
"label": "corrected claims",
"value": 2,
"line": 6
},
{
"label": "unverified claims",
"value": 1,
"line": 7
},
{
"label": "packet claim arithmetic",
"value": 3,
"line": 8
},
{
"label": "wallet btc balance",
"value": 42.5,
"line": 16
},
{
"label": "wallet eth balance",
"value": 310,
"line": 17
},
{
"label": "wallet holdings arithmetic",
"value": 42.5,
"line": 18
},
{
"label": "wallet btc balance",
"value": 97.25,
"line": 20
},
{
"label": "check fee",
"value": 100,
"line": 25
},
{
"label": "review fee",
"value": 150,
"line": 26
},
{
"label": "total",
"value": 300,
"line": 27
},
{
"label": "packet total",
"value": 6,
"line": 29
}
]
}